| Date | | Opponents | Competition | Score | Attendance | Scorers |
| 2023-24 |
Mon | 02-Oct-2023 | | LEVERSTOCK GREEN | HSC (R1) | 1-1(Pens 4-3) | 113 | Temi Akinbusoye | |
| 2022-23 |
Mon | 19-Sep-2022 | | WELWYN GARDEN CITY | HSC (R1) | 1-0 | 231 | Ashley Hay | |
Sat | 29-Oct-2022 | | POTTERS BAR TOWN | HSC (R2) | 3-2 | 339 | Diogo Freitas-Gouveia, Steve Cawley (Pen), Ashley Hay | |
Mon | 09-Jan-2023 | | STEVENAGE | HSC (R3) | 1-0 | 361 | Finley Wilkinson (Pen) | |
Tue | 28-Feb-2023 | | Cheshunt | HSC (SF) | 2-0 | 241 | Toby Syme, Ashley Hay | |
Wed | 29-Mar-2023 | | Berkhamsted | HSC (Fin) | 2-2(Theobalds Lane, Cheshunt Pens 2-4) | 461 | Finley Wilkinson, Jack Snelus | |
| 2021-22 |
Tue | 23-Nov-2021 | | Tring Athletic | HSC (R1) | 4-0 | 81 | Lewis Barker, Steve Cawley, Rio Dasilva, Callum Stead | |
Tue | 18-Jan-2022 | | St Albans City | HSC (QF) | 2-2(Pens 5-3) | 251 | Jake Hutchinson (2) | |
Tue | 15-Mar-2022 | | Cheshunt | HSC (SF) | 0-2(AET) | 172 | - | |
| 2019-20 |
Mon | 25-Nov-2019 | | WELWYN GARDEN CITY | HSC (R2) | 1-1(Pens 4-3) | 78 | Max Ryan | |
Tue | 07-Jan-2020 | | Leverstock Green | HSC (R4) | 2-0 | 40 | Daniel Webb, Jacob Hutchinson (Pen) | |
Tue | 11-Feb-2020 | | Hemel Hempstead Town | HSC (QF) | 2-3 | 103 | Alex Marsh (2) | |
| 2018-19 |
Wed | 07-Nov-2018 | | TRING ATHLETIC | HSC (R1) | 2-1 | 79 | Trey Charles, Scott Belgrove | |
Wed | 05-Dec-2018 | | HEMEL HEMPSTEAD TOWN | HSC (R2) | 0-0(Pens 1-4) | 79 | - | |
| 2017-18 |
Mon | 04-Dec-2017 | | BISHOP'S STORTFORD | HSC (R1) | 3-0 | 143 | Trey Charles (2), Conor Vincent | |
Mon | 29-Jan-2018 | | BOREHAM WOOD | HSC (R2) | 0-3 | 206 | - | |
| 2016-17 |
Wed | 07-Dec-2016 | | Hadley | HSC (R2) | 3-0 | 61 | Mason Spence (2), Ben Walster (Pen) | |
Tue | 10-Jan-2017 | | St Albans City | HSC (QF) | 2-2(Pens 5-3) | 183 | Kane Smith, Will Wright | |
Mon | 06-Feb-2017 | | CHESHUNT | HSC (SF) | 3-1 | 162 | Robbie Burns (2), Matt Lench | |
Tue | 11-Apr-2017 | | Bishop's Stortford | HSC (Fin) | 2-1(Hemel Hempstead Town) | 325 | Will Wright (2) | |
| 2015-16 |
Tue | 03-Nov-2015 | | Colney Heath | HSC (R1) | 2-1 | 95 | Daniel Webb, Robbie Burns | |
Tue | 15-Dec-2015 | | Sun Sports | HSC (R2) | 5-0 | | Simon Martin, Callum Donnelly (2), Lucas Kirkpatrick, Matt Lench | |
Mon | 18-Jan-2016 | | CHESHUNT | HSC (QF) | 1-0 | 101 | Lucas Kirkpatrick | |
Mon | 08-Feb-2016 | | ST ALBANS CITY | HSC (SF) | 2-0 | 136 | Lewis Rolfe, Robbie Burns | |
Thu | 05-May-2016 | | Boreham Wood | HSC (Fin) | 2-1(Cheshunt) | 366 | Liam Brooks, Daniel Webb | |
| 2014-15 |
Tue | 11-Nov-2014 | | Hertford Town | HSC (R1) | 2-3 | 72 | Brett Donnelly, Lewis Rolfe | |
| 2013-14 |
Mon | 04-Nov-2013 | | OXHEY JETS | HSC (R1) | 4-0 | 71 | Simon Martin, Robbie Burns, Gary Wharton, Michael King | |
Mon | 02-Dec-2013 | | HODDESDON TOWN | HSC (R2) | 3-3(Pens 3-2) | 81 | Gary Wharton (2), Terry Dixon | |
Tue | 21-Jan-2014 | | STEVENAGE | HSC (QF) | 1-0 | 182 | Matt Lench | |
Thu | 27-Mar-2014 | | BOREHAM WOOD | HSC (SF) | 0-1 | 101 | - | |
| 2012-13 |
Mon | 05-Nov-2012 | | BOREHAM WOOD | HSC (R1) | 3-0 | 101 | Callum Donnelly (2), John Frendo | |
Mon | 03-Dec-2012 | | POTTERS BAR TOWN | HSC (R2) | 0-3 | 86 | - | |
| 2011-12 |
Mon | 31-Oct-2011 | | TRING ATHLETIC | HSC (R1) | 3-1 | 101 | Jerome Anderson, Louis Lee, Jamie Arlick | |
Tue | 06-Dec-2011 | | STEVENAGE | HSC (R2) | 0-2 | 159 | - | |
| 2010-11 |
Tue | 09-Nov-2010 | | WARE | HSC (R1) | 3-4 | 64 | Richard Howell (2), Liam George | |
| 2009-10 |
Tue | 10-Nov-2009 | | Leverstock Green | HSC (R1) | 1-2 | | Jamie Arlick | |
| 2008-09 |
Tue | 25-Nov-2008 | | Broxbourne Borough V&E | HSC (R1) | 2-1 | 71 | Ian Hilaire, Scott Balderson | |
Tue | 02-Dec-2008 | | Cheshunt | HSC (R2) | 2-3 | 101 | Mark Barnes (2) | |
| 2007-08 |
Tue | 06-Nov-2007 | | COLNEY HEATH | HSC (R1) | 3-0 | 64 | Glen Lamacraft, David Iwediuno, Martin Standen (Pen) | |
Tue | 04-Dec-2007 | | Hemel Hempstead Town | HSC (R2) | 0-3 | 125 | - | |
| 2006-07 |
Tue | 31-Oct-2006 | | TRING ATHLETIC | HSC (R1) | 5-0 | 82 | Mark Bridge (2), Josh Sozzo (3) | |
Tue | 05-Dec-2006 | | BISHOP'S STORTFORD | HSC (R2) | 0-1 | 91 | - | |
| 2005-06 |
Tue | 08-Nov-2005 | | HEMEL HEMPSTEAD TOWN | HSC (R1) | 2-3 | 82 | Thomas Hayes, Mark Bridge | |
| 2004-05 |
Tue | 16-Nov-2004 | | Potters Bar Town | HSC (R2) | 1-2 | 50 | Lee McCulloch | |
| 2003-04 |
Tue | 14-Oct-2003 | | BROXBOURNE BOROUGH V&E | HSC (R1) | 8-1 | 76 | Chris Dillon (4), Adam Parker (3), Ryan Nicholl | |
Tue | 09-Dec-2003 | | ROYSTON TOWN | HSC (R2) | 3-0 | 68 | Mark Bridge (2), Ryan Nicholl | |
Tue | 20-Jan-2004 | | Berkhamsted Town | HSC (R3) | 6-3 | | Jon Bone, Mark Bridge (2), Ryan Frater, Dean McElroy, Josh Sozzo | |
Mon | 23-Feb-2004 | | WATFORD | HSC (SF) | 1-3 | 156 | Jon Bone | |
| 2002-03 |
Tue | 19-Nov-2002 | | London Colney | HSC (R2) | 2-0 | 87 | Carl Drew, Matt Nolan | |
Tue | 28-Jan-2003 | | Watford | HSC (R3) | 2-1(AET) | 168 | Dean Brennan, Wayne Mills | |
Tue | 25-Feb-2003 | | Berkhamsted Town | HSC (SF) | 2-4 | | Mark Bridge (2) | |
| 2001-02 |
Tue | 09-Oct-2001 | | Cheshunt | HSC (R1) | 1-0 | | Robbie Simpson (Pen) | |
Tue | 13-Nov-2001 | | SAWBRIDGEWORTH TOWN | HSC (R2) | 2-0 | 96 | Carl Drew, Matt Nolan | |
Tue | 08-Jan-2002 | | STEVENAGE BOROUGH | HSC (R3) | 3-1 | 171 | Carl Drew, Matt Nolan, Robbie Simpson | |
Tue | 19-Feb-2002 | | Boreham Wood | HSC (SF) | 1-6 | | Craig Rydeheard | |
| 2000-01 |
Tue | 10-Oct-2000 | | HEMEL HEMPSTEAD TOWN | HSC (R1) | 5-1 | 117 | Cliff Akurang, Adam Parker (3), Matt Nolan | |
Tue | 24-Oct-2000 | | LONDON COLNEY | HSC (R2) | 7-0 | 121 | Jeran Meah, Adam Parker (2), Robert Kean, Shaun Marshall (Pen), Matt Nolan (2) | |
Tue | 09-Jan-2001 | | STEVENAGE BOROUGH | HSC (R3) | 1-2 | 405 | Craig Rydeheard | |
| 1999-00 |
Tue | 02-Nov-1999 | | LONDON COLNEY | HSC (R2) | 3-2 | 158 | Darren Fenton (3) | |
Tue | 07-Dec-1999 | | ST ALBANS CITY | HSC (R3) | 1-5 | 141 | Mark Burke | |
| 1998-99 |
Tue | 20-Oct-1998 | | ST ALBANS CITY | HSC (R1) | 3-4 | 202 | Zeema Abbey (2), Gary Dixon | |
| 1997-98 |
Tue | 14-Oct-1997 | | POTTERS BAR TOWN | HSC (R1) | 4-1 | 90 | Barry Dellar (2), Gary Williams, Carl Williams | |
Tue | 25-Nov-1997 | | London Colney | HSC (R2) | 4-0 | | Shaun Debnam, Barry Dellar, Nick Grime, Andrew Barr | |
Tue | 30-Dec-1997 | | Watford | HSC (R3) | 2-5(AET) | 231 | Barry Dellar (2) | |
| 1996-97 |
Tue | 15-Oct-1996 | | HEMEL HEMPSTEAD TOWN | HSC (R1) | 9-0 | | John Coley, Adam Parker (2), Rudi Hall (3-2 Pens), Dave Cooper, Tim Allpress, Dave Drury | |
Tue | 26-Nov-1996 | | POTTERS BAR TOWN | HSC (R2) | 3-0 | | Dave Cooper (2), Barry Dellar | |
Mon | 20-Jan-1997 | | WELWYN GARDEN CITY | HSC (R3) | 4-0 | 160 | Corey Donahue (2), Adam Parker, Dave Cooper (Pen) | |
Tue | 25-Feb-1997 | | London Colney | HSC (SF) | 3-0 | | Corey Donahue, Carl Williams, Adam Parker | |
Mon | 05-May-1997 | | Boreham Wood | HSC (Fin) | 4-1(Clarence Park) | 500 | Mark Burke, Rudi Hall (2-1 Pen), Barry Dellar | |
| 1995-96 |
Tue | 05-Dec-1995 | | Hertford Town | HSC (R2) | 6-0 | 60 | Gary Roberts, Steve Conroy (3), Gary Issot (2) | |
Tue | 30-Jan-1996 | | BISHOP'S STORTFORD | HSC (QF) | 4-1(AET) | 192 | Gary Williams (2), Mark Burke, OG,? | |
Tue | 26-Mar-1996 | | Barnet | HSC (SF) | 0-1 | 284 | - | |
| 1994-95 |
Tue | 18-Oct-1994 | | WARE | HSC (R2) | 2-1(AET) | 163 | Tony Caines (2) | |
Tue | 31-Jan-1995 | | Boreham Wood | HSC (QF) | 1-0 | 147 | Paul Ripley | |
Thu | 30-Mar-1995 | | Watford | HSC (SF) | 1-3 | 174 | Alan Cosby | |
| 1993-94 |
Tue | 02-Nov-1993 | | Bishop's Stortford | HSC (R1) | 0-3 | 351 | - | |
| 1992-93 |
Tue | 20-Oct-1992 | | BISHOP'S STORTFORD | HSC (R1) | 0-2 | 222 | - | |
| 1991-92 |
Tue | 01-Oct-1991 | | Bishop's Stortford | HSC (R1) | 1-4 | 279 | Mark Burke | |
| 1990-91 |
Tue | 09-Oct-1990 | | STEVENAGE BOROUGH | HSC (R1) | 1-2 | 532 | Jason Reed | |
| 1989-90 |
Mon | 23-Oct-1989 | | Barnet | HSC (R1) | 2-3 | 462 | Steve Conroy (2) | |
| 1988-89 |
Tue | 01-Nov-1988 | | Boreham Wood | HSC (R1) | 0-2 | | - | |
| 1987-88 |
Tue | 17-Nov-1987 | | Barnet | HSC (R1) | 2-1(AET) | 269 | Mick Every, Ronnie Lawson | |
Wed | 27-Jan-1988 | | Tring Town | HSC (R2) | 5-6(AET) | | Trevor Parker, Chris Goode (2), Alan Cosby (2-1 Pen) | |
| 1986-87 |
Tue | 28-Oct-1986 | | WATFORD | HSC (R1) | 5-1 | 130 | Carl Stock (2), Robbie O'Keefe (2-1 Pen), Trevor Parker | |
Tue | 03-Feb-1987 | | STEVENAGE BOROUGH | HSC (R2) | 0-4 | 549 | - | |
| 1985-86 |
Tue | 28-Jan-1986 | | Royston Town | HSC (R2) | 4-1 | | Steve Fountain, Mark Thomas (2), Mick Every | |
Mon | 10-Mar-1986 | | BARNET | HSC (SF) | 0-2 | 194 | - | |
| 1984-85 |
Tue | 30-Oct-1984 | | BOREHAM WOOD | HSC (R1) | 2-1 | 161 | Steve Miller, Ray Brammer | |
Tue | 29-Jan-1985 | | ST ALBANS CITY | HSC (R2) | 1-0(AET) | 220 | Mark Thomas | |
Tue | 19-Feb-1985 | | Watford (R) | HSC (SF) | 1-3 | 288 | Ray Brammer | |
| 1983-84 |
Wed | 02-Nov-1983 | | Tring Town | HSC (R1) | 3-2(AET) | | Steve Gear, Mick Every (2) | |
Sat | 10-Dec-1983 | | Welwyn Garden City | HSC (R2) | 2-1 | | Alan West, Mick Every | |
Sat | 28-Jan-1984 | | BALDOCK TOWN | HSC (R3) | 4-1 | 351 | Alan West, Neil Madden, Steve Fountain (Pen), OG (Bickerstaffe) | |
Tue | 13-Mar-1984 | | HERTFORD TOWN | HSC (SF) | 1-2 | 191 | Alan West | |
| 1982-83 |
Sat | 30-Oct-1982 | | Ware | HSC (R1) | 7-2 | | Peter Harvey (3), Trevor Parker (3), Paul Grant | |
Tue | 14-Dec-1982 | | WATFORD | HSC (R2) | 2-4 | 204 | Alan Cosby, Mick Every (Pen) | |
| 1981-82 |
Sat | 05-Dec-1981 | | Highfield | HSC (R2) | 10-2 | | Steve Mahoney (6-1 Pen), Mick Every (4) | |
Mon | 25-Jan-1982 | | BISHOP'S STORTFORD | HSC (QF) | 1-3(AET) | 268 | Mick Every | |
| 1980-81 |
Sat | 13-Dec-1980 | | PIRTON | HSC (R2) | 2-2(AET) | 312 | Mick Small, Steve Mahoney | |
Sat | 20-Dec-1980 | | Pirton | HSC (R2) | 1-0(AET) | | Steve Mahoney | |
Sat | 07-Feb-1981 | | Boreham Wood | HSC (QF) | 2-2(AET) | | Steve Mahoney, Kevin Mulkern | |
Tue | 10-Feb-1981 | | BOREHAM WOOD | HSC (QF) | 1-1(Pens 3-2) | 263 | Steve Mahoney | |
Thu | 26-Mar-1981 | | Watford | HSC (SF) | 2-3(AET) | 546 | Mick Small, Andy Pearson | |
| 1979-80 |
Sat | 22-Dec-1979 | | CHESHUNT | HSC (R2) | 4-0 | 175 | Steve Hodge, Colin Barnes (3) | |
Sat | 16-Feb-1980 | | Bishop's Stortford | HSC (R2) | 3-1 | | Mick Sorenson, George Cooper, Paul Giggle | |
Sat | 08-Mar-1980 | | BOREHAM WOOD | HSC (SF) | 4-4(AET) | 326 | Steve Hodge (2), Colin Barnes, Paul Giggle | |
Tue | 11-Mar-1980 | | Boreham Wood | HSC (SF) | 1-2(AET) | | Paul Giggle | |
| 1978-79 |
Tue | 12-Dec-1978 | | Letchworth Garden City | HSC (R2) | 6-3 | | Bobby Carroll (Pen), Kevin Hammond, Adrian Taylor, Paul Giggle (2), Gary Harthill | |
Tue | 06-Feb-1979 | | BISHOP'S STORTFORD | HSC (R3) | 3-4 | 207 | Paul Giggle, Jim McCarthy, Kevin Mulkern | |
| 1977-78 |
Mon | 14-Nov-1977 | | Watford | HSC (R2) | 2-4 | 714 | Jose Whishaw, Peter Watson (Pen) | |
| 1976-77 |
Wed | 05-Jan-1977 | | LEGGATTS WAY OLD BOYS | HSC (R2) | 4-0 | 176 | Jose Whishaw, Kevin Mulkern (2), Paul Giggle (Pen) | |
Tue | 15-Feb-1977 | | LETCHWORTH GARDEN CITY | HSC (R3) | 3-2 | 644 | Bobby Brown, Neil Bunker, Paul Giggle | |
Sat | 12-Mar-1977 | | BOREHAM WOOD | HSC (SF) | 2-0 | 494 | Dave Archibald, Hugh Wilson | |
Mon | 11-Apr-1977 | | Bishop's Stortford | HSC (Fin) | 2-0(Hertford Town) | 1700 | Peter Watson (2) | |
| 1975-76 |
Sat | 13-Dec-1975 | | ROYSTON TOWN | HSC (R2) | 3-0 | 226 | David Webb, Tony Brothers, Neil Bunker | |
Tue | 10-Feb-1976 | | Barnet | HSC (R3) | 0-1(AET) | 299 | - | |
| 1974-75 |
Sat | 04-Jan-1975 | | BALDOCK TOWN | HSC (R2) | 3-0 | 480 | John Kettleborough, Neil Bunker, Howard Kettleborough | |
Sat | 08-Feb-1975 | | CHESHUNT | HSC (QF) | 2-0 | 320 | Howard Kettleborough (Pen), Neil Bunker | |
Sat | 15-Mar-1975 | | Hemel Hempstead | HSC (SF) | 1-0 | | Neil Bunker | |
Fri | 25-Apr-1975 | | Boreham Wood | HSC (Fin) | 2-0(Hertford Town) | | Howard Kettleborough, Neil Bunker | |
| 1973-74 |
Sat | 19-Jan-1974 | | Hertford Town | HSC (R1) | 3-0 | 469 | Alan Jackett (Pen), Paul Giggle, Howard Kettleborough | |
Sat | 09-Mar-1974 | | Bishop's Stortford | HSC (R3) | 0-2 | | - | |
| 1972-73 |
Sat | 13-Jan-1973 | | St Albans City | HSC (R1) | 1-0 | 500 | Paul Giggle | |
Sat | 10-Feb-1973 | | Hemel Hempstead | HSC (R2) | 3-2 | | Ray Hill (3) | |
Sat | 17-Mar-1973 | | HODDESDON TOWN | HSC (SF) | 3-1 | 422 | John Kettleborough, Ray Hill, Paul Giggle | |
Mon | 23-Apr-1973 | | Bishop's Stortford | HSC (Fin) | 0-2(St Albans City AET) | 930 | - | |
| 1971-72 |
Sat | 05-Feb-1972 | | ST ALBANS CITY | HSC (R2) | 1-1(AET) | 719 | Alan Garofall | |
Tue | 14-Mar-1972 | | St Albans City | HSC (R2) | 1-0 | 750 | Tony Smith | |
Sat | 25-Mar-1972 | | Hertford Town | HSC (QF) | 2-1 | 550 | Tony Smith, Dave Allaway | |
Sat | 01-Apr-1972 | | Boreham Wood | HSC (SF) | 2-3 | 600 | Dave Allaway (2) | |
| 1970-71 |
Sat | 13-Feb-1971 | | HERTFORD TOWN | HSC (QF) | 5-1 | 405 | Bernie Mapp, Bernie Gogan, John Brookes (Pen), Paul Giggle (2-1 Pen) | |
Sat | 13-Mar-1971 | | BISHOP'S STORTFORD | HSC (SF) | 4-4 | 503 | Tony Harley, Bernie Gogan (2), Paul Giggle | |
Sat | 20-Mar-1971 | | Bishop's Stortford | HSC (SF) | 0-1(AET) | | - | |
| 1969-70 |
Sat | 17-Jan-1970 | | HEMEL HEMPSTEAD TOWN | HSC (R3) | 5-0 | 554 | Paul Giggle (2), Roy Cutler, Bernie Gogan (2) | |
Sat | 21-Feb-1970 | | Baldock Town | HSC (R4) | 4-1 | 750 | Ian Reid, Charlie Townsend, Ken Fulkes, Bernie Gogan | |
Tue | 14-Apr-1970 | | HERTFORD TOWN | HSC (SF) | 1-1 | | Bernie Gogan | |
Tue | 28-Apr-1970 | | Hertford Town | HSC (SF) | 2-1(AET) | | Roy Cutler, Bernie Gogan | |
Tue | 05-May-1970 | | Cheshunt | HSC (Fin) | 1-0(Bishops Stortford AET) | 1809 | Tony Brothers | |
| 1968-69 |
Sat | 25-Jan-1969 | | BERKHAMSTED TOWN | HSC (R3) | 4-1 | 597 | Martin Gladwin, Bernie Gogan, Hugh Pratt, OG (Wishart) | |
Thu | 27-Feb-1969 | | CHESHUNT | HSC (R4) | 1-2 | 334 | Bernie Gogan | |
| 1967-68 |
Tue | 30-Jan-1968 | | HODDESDON TOWN | HSC (R1) | 2-1 | 574 | Terry Waldock, Bernie Gogan | |
Sat | 17-Feb-1968 | | Bishop's Stortford | HSC (R2) | 2-1 | 800 | Ken Fulkes, Bernie Gogan | |
Sat | 09-Mar-1968 | | Hertford Town | HSC (SF) | 1-2 | | Bernie Gogan | |
| 1966-67 |
Sat | 04-Feb-1967 | | Cheshunt | HSC (R1) | 0-1 | | - | |
| 1965-66 |
Sat | 15-Jan-1966 | | Tring Town | HSC (R3) | 1-0 | | Ron Crawley | |
Sat | 05-Mar-1966 | | St Albans City | HSC (R4) | 0-5 | 1315 | - | |
| 1964-65 |
Sat | 16-Jan-1965 | | Hemel Hempstead Town | HSC (R3) | 3-0 | | Kilby Edwards (3) | |
Sat | 20-Feb-1965 | | Letchworth Town | HSC (SF) | 1-3 | 1103 | Kilby Edwards | |
| 1963-64 |
Sat | 18-Jan-1964 | | RICKMANSWORTH TOWN | HSC (R3) | 8-0 | 624 | John Graves, Terry Waldock (3), Danny Desmond (2), Tommy Everitt, Tony Horne | |
Sat | 15-Feb-1964 | | Barnet | HSC (R4) | 1-3 | | OG (Voyce) | |
| 1962-63 |
Sat | 23-Mar-1963 | | St Albans City | HSC (R4) | 0-1 | | - | |
| 1961-62 |
Sat | 13-Jan-1962 | | TRING TOWN | HSC (R3) | 11-0 | 1107 | Terry Craddock, Dennis Randall (4), John Graves, Terry Waldock (3), Peter Cox, OG (Sharpe) | |
Sat | 03-Feb-1962 | | HODDESDON TOWN | HSC (R4) | 12-1 | 1304 | Peter Hutchinson, Terry Waldock (2), Dennis Randall (7), John Graves (Pen), Peter Clarke | |
Sat | 10-Mar-1962 | | St Albans City | HSC (SF) | 7-4 | 1754 | Terry Waldock, Dennis Randall (4), John Graves, Peter Hutchinson | |
Mon | 23-Apr-1962 | | Hemel Hempstead Town | HSC (Fin) | 2-0(Watford) | 2771 | Terry Waldock (2) | |
| 1960-61 |
Sat | 07-Jan-1961 | | LEAVESDEN HOSPITAL | HSC (R3) | 3-0 | 931 | Terry Craddock (Pen), Terry Waldock, Dennis Randall | |
Sat | 11-Feb-1961 | | HERTFORD TOWN | HSC (R4) | 5-0 | 2087 | Terry Craddock (Pen), Terry Waldock, John Mantell (2), John Graves | |
Sat | 11-Mar-1961 | | Barnet | HSC (SF) | 3-4 | | Terry Craddock (Pen), Terry Waldock (2) | |
| 1959-60 |
Sat | 16-Jan-1960 | | KINGS LANGLEY | HSC (R3) | 6-0 | 446 | Terry Craddock (3), Roger Figg (2), OG (Burnell) | |
Sat | 13-Feb-1960 | | BARNET | HSC (R4) | 1-4 | 1051 | Terry Craddock | |
| 1958-59 |
Sat | 22-Nov-1958 | | Stevenage Town | HSC (R3) | 1-3 | | Peter Hammond (Pen) | |
| 1957-58 |
Sat | 15-Feb-1958 | | Letchworth Town | HSC (R4) | 1-0 | 1867 | Neville Overman | |
Sat | 29-Mar-1958 | | Barnet | HSC (SF) | 1-3 | | OG (d'Arcy) | |
| 1956-57 |
Sat | 19-Jan-1957 | | CHESHUNT | HSC (R3) | 4-2 | 1449 | Roger Simmonds (2), Peter Hammond, Alec Smith | |
Sat | 16-Feb-1957 | | BERKHAMSTED TOWN | HSC (R4) | 3-0 | 1196 | Roger Simmonds (2), Peter Hammond | |
Sat | 09-Mar-1957 | | BARNET | HSC (SF) | 2-1 | 1660 | John Lay, Arthur Flint (Pen) | |
Mon | 22-Apr-1957 | | St Albans City | HSC (Fin) | 1-5(Barnet) | 1866 | Brian Figg | |
| 1955-56 |
Sat | 25-Feb-1956 | | LETCHWORTH TOWN | HSC (R4) | 3-4 | 1785 | Brian Figg (3) | |
| 1954-55 |
Sat | 05-Feb-1955 | | TRING TOWN | HSC (R3) | 6-0 | 917 | Brian Figg, David Bumpstead, Alec Smith (4) | |
Sat | 26-Feb-1955 | | Ware | HSC (R4) | 3-0 | | Peter Hammond (2-1 Pen), Alec Smith | |
Sat | 19-Mar-1955 | | St Albans City | HSC (SF) | 1-2 | 2368 | Dave Sayers | |
| 1953-54 |
Sat | 28-Nov-1953 | | STEVENAGE TOWN | HSC (R1) | 2-1 | 3085 | Johnny Ward, Ray Kitchener | |
Sat | 05-Dec-1953 | | BISHOP'S STORTFORD | HSC (R2) | 1-2 | 1977 | Jack Fisher (Pen) | |
| 1952-53 |
Sat | 22-Nov-1952 | | STEVENAGE TOWN | HSC (R1) | 1-1 | 1303 | Ray Kitchener | |
Sat | 29-Nov-1952 | | Stevenage Town | HSC (R1) | 1-4 | | Brian Smith | |
| 1951-52 |
Sat | 16-Feb-1952 | | St Albans City | HSC (R3) | 1-3 | 1837 | Dennis d'Arcy | |
| 1950-51 |
Sat | 20-Jan-1951 | | BISHOP'S STORTFORD | HSC (R1) | 2-0 | | Claude Brown, Jova Jovanovic | |
Sat | 17-Feb-1951 | | RICKMANSWORTH TOWN | HSC (R2) | 2-1(AET) | 771 | Ken Lawrence, Jova Jovanovic | |
Sat | 24-Feb-1951 | | Rickmansworth Town | HSC (R2) | 3-2 | 297 | Ken Chambers, Keith Abbiss, Harry Hillier | |
Sat | 10-Mar-1951 | | BERKHAMSTED TOWN | HSC (SF) | 4-0 | | Stan Tarrant, Ken Chambers (2), Harry Hillier | |
Sat | 05-May-1951 | | St Albans City | HSC (Fin) | 0-3(Barnet) | | - | |
| 1949-50 |
Sat | 18-Feb-1950 | | Cheshunt | HSC (R5) | 0-1 | 1708 | - | |
| 1948-49 |
Sat | 08-Jan-1949 | | Stevenage Town | HSC (R3) | 3-2 | 1386 | Dick Cole (2), Taffy Rogers | |
Sat | 05-Feb-1949 | | Letchworth Town | HSC (R4) | 3-1 | 3696 | Arthur Ward (2), Edgar Britten | |
Sat | 12-Mar-1949 | | CHESHUNT | HSC (SF) | 1-4 | 1782 | Larry Dolan | |
| 1947-48 |
Sat | 07-Feb-1948 | | BARNET | HSC (R1) | 2-4 | 3000 | Johnny Mockler, Frank Wingate | |
| 1946-47 |
Sat | 19-Apr-1947 | | Barnet | HSC (R3) | 1-2 | | Frank Wingate | |
| 1945-46 |
Sat | 16-Mar-1946 | | BARNET | HSC (R3) | 0-2 | | - | |
| 1938-39 |
Sat | 28-Jan-1939 | | Letchworth Town | HSC (R2) | 2-0 | | Sam Hailey (2) | |
Sat | 11-Feb-1939 | | BERKHAMSTED TOWN | HSC (R3) | 6-0 | | Les Bland, Syd Wilkinson, Frank Kilby, Sam Hailey (2), Les Clarke | |
Sat | 01-Apr-1939 | | ST ALBANS CITY | HSC (SF) | 2-0 | | Bill Westwood, Les Clarke | |
Sat | 06-May-1939 | | Leavesden Mental Hospital | HSC (Fin) | 1-1(AET) | | Dick Murphy | |
Wed | 10-May-1939 | | Leavesden Mental Hospital | HSC (Fin) | 3-0(Letchworth) | 2200 | Sam Hailey, Sid Gentle, Jack Hoar | |
| 1937-38 |
Sat | 22-Jan-1938 | | Letchworth Town | HSC (R2) | 5-0 | | Eric Broadbent, Sam Hailey, Les Clarke (2), Jack Hoar | |
Sat | 12-Feb-1938 | | Hertford Town | HSC (R3) | 3-1 | | Eric Broadbent, Sam Hailey, Les Clarke | |
Sat | 12-Mar-1938 | | WARE | HSC (SF) | 6-0 | | Dick Murphy, Les Clarke, Jack Hoar (4) | |
Sat | 07-May-1938 | | LEAVESDEN MENTAL HOSPITAL | HSC (Fin) | 4-1 | | Sam Hailey (2), Syd Wilkinson, Jack Hoar | |
| 1936-37 |
Sat | 05-Dec-1936 | | WHITE CITY | HSC (R1) | 1-0 | | Dick Murphy | |
Sat | 23-Jan-1937 | | BISHOP'S STORTFORD | HSC (R2) | 6-2 | | Les Bland, Bill Westwood, Ray Albone (2), Jack Hoar (2) | |
Sat | 20-Feb-1937 | | LEAVESDEN MENTAL HOSPITAL | HSC (SF) | 0-0(AET) | | - | |
Sat | 20-Mar-1937 | | LEAVESDEN MENTAL HOSPITAL | HSC (SF) | 1-2 | | Eric Broadbent | |
| 1935-36 |
Sat | 30-Nov-1935 | | Hertford Town | HSC (R1) | 3-1 | | Phil Chamberlain (2), Harry Buswell | |
Wed | 29-Jan-1936 | | LEAVESDEN MENTAL HOSPITAL | HSC (R2) | 2-6 | | Eric Broadbent, Dick Murphy | |
| 1934-35 |
Sat | 09-Feb-1935 | | Stevenage Town | HSC (R2) | 5-0 | | Jimmy Walker (3), Cyril Walker, Les Clarke | |
Sat | 16-Feb-1935 | | St Albans City | HSC (R3) | 0-2 | | - | |
| 1933-34 |
Sat | 25-Nov-1933 | | KNEBWORTH | HSC (R1) | 7-1 | | Jimmy Walker, Eddie Armitage (3), Harry French (2), Reg Smith | |
Sat | 13-Jan-1934 | | BUSHEY UNITED | HSC (R2) | 10-1 | | Sid King (3), Harry French, Eddie Armitage, Dick Foss (3), Reg Smith (2) | |
Sat | 10-Feb-1934 | | APSLEY | HSC (R3) | 2-1 | | Jimmy Walker (2) | |
Sat | 24-Feb-1934 | | Apsley | HSC (R3) | 3-1 | | R Quince, Eddie Armitage (2) | |
Sat | 17-Mar-1934 | | Berkhamsted Town | HSC (SF) | 1-1 | | Eddie Armitage | |
Sat | 07-Apr-1934 | | BERKHAMSTED TOWN | HSC (SF) | 3-1 | | Sid King, Jimmy Walker, Arthur Cawdell | |
Sat | 05-May-1934 | | Hertford Town | HSC (Fin) | 3-2(Barnet AET) | | Sid King, Jimmy Walker (Pen), Eddie Armitage | |
| 1932-33 |
Sat | 21-Jan-1933 | | Hoddesdon Town | HSC (R2) | 1-3 | | Billy Izzard | |
| 1931-32 |
Sat | 23-Jan-1932 | | WELWYN GARDEN CITY | HSC (R2) | 11-2 | | Ron Lynch, Jimmy Walker, Eddie Armitage (7), Albert Tasker, Dick Dunkley | |
Sat | 13-Feb-1932 | | WATFORD SPARTANS | HSC (R3) | 9-0 | | Ron Lynch, Jimmy Walker (2), Eddie Armitage (3), George Payne (3) | |
Sat | 12-Mar-1932 | | SHREDDED WHEAT | HSC (SF) | 1-1 | | Jimmy Walker | |
Sat | 19-Mar-1932 | | Shredded Wheat | HSC (SF) | 2-2 | | Jack Hall, Eddie Armitage | |
Sat | 16-Apr-1932 | | SHREDDED WHEAT | HSC (SF) | 6-0 | | Jimmy Walker (2), Eddie Armitage (2), Albert Tasker (2) | |
Sat | 14-May-1932 | | Apsley | HSC (Fin) | 5-1(St Albans City) | | Eddie Armitage (3), Billy Izzard, Ron Lynch | |
| 1930-31 |
Sat | 24-Jan-1931 | | BISHOP'S STORTFORD | HSC (R2) | 7-4(AET) | | George Pateman (2), Stan Millard, Ken Brown, Albert Tasker, Harry French (2) | |
Sat | 14-Feb-1931 | | BUSHEY UNITED | HSC (R3) | 7-4 | | George Trussell, George Pateman, Jack Hall (2), Stan Millard (2), Reg Smith | |
Sat | 14-Mar-1931 | | HERTFORD TOWN | HSC (SF) | 3-0 | | Harry French (2), Albert Tasker | |
Sat | 18-Apr-1931 | | Leavesden Mental Hospital | HSC (Fin) | 0-0(St Albans City) | | - | |
Thu | 30-Apr-1931 | | Leavesden Mental Hospital | HSC (Fin) | 3-0(Letchworth) | | Stan Millard, Robert Brown, Harry French | |
| 1929-30 |
Sat | 25-Jan-1930 | | LETCHWORTH TOWN | HSC (R2) | 3-5(AET) | 3000 | Ted Bullard, Jack Oyston, Albert Tasker | |
| 1928-29 |
Sat | 19-Jan-1929 | | Letchworth Town | HSC (R2) | 8-2 | | J Thompson, Charlie Evans (2), Harry Wombwell (4), Albert Tasker | |
Sat | 23-Feb-1929 | | Baldock Town | HSC (R3) | 4-3 | | Charlie Evans (2), Harold Hanscombe (2) | |
Sat | 09-Mar-1929 | | St Albans City | HSC (SF) | 2-6 | 3000 | Jack Davey, J Thompson (Pen) | |