| Date | Opponents | Result | Score | Competition | Scorers |
| 28/02/2023 | Cheshunt | Won | 2-0 | Herts Senior Cup | Toby Syme,Ashley Hay | |
| 15/03/2022 | Cheshunt | Lost | 0-2 | Herts Senior Cup | | |
| 18/09/2021 | CHESHUNT | Lost | 0-3 | Emirates FA Cup | | |
| 28/10/2017 | CHESHUNT | Won | 5-0 | Buildbase FA Trophy | Daniel Webb,Jack Green,Elliot Bailey,Brett Donnelly,Trey Charles | |
| 28/03/2017 | Cheshunt | Lost | 0-1 | Herts Charity Cup | | |
| 06/02/2017 | CHESHUNT | Won | 3-1 | Herts Senior Cup | Robbie Burns (2),Matt Lench | |
| 18/01/2016 | CHESHUNT | Won | 1-0 | Herts Senior Cup | Lucas Kirkpatrick | |
| 04/08/2014 | CHESHUNT | Won | 4-1 | Herts Charity Cup | Robbie Burns,Charlie Smith,Lewis Rolfe (2-1 Pen) | |
| 11/08/2009 | CHESHUNT | Won | 2-1 | Herts Charity Cup | Neil Thompson,Richard Howell | |
| 02/12/2008 | Cheshunt | Lost | 2-3 | Herts Senior Cup | Mark Barnes (2) | |
| 01/01/2008 | CHESHUNT | Won | 3-1 | British Gas Business League | Brett Donnelly (2),David Deeney (Pen) | |
| 11/12/2007 | Cheshunt | Lost | 1-2 | Herts Charity Cup | James Edgerley | |
| 01/09/2007 | Cheshunt | Won | 2-1 | British Gas Business League | Jon Stevenson,Shane Hill (Pen) | |
| 06/02/2007 | CHESHUNT | Lost | 0-1 | Southern League | | |
| 28/10/2006 | Cheshunt | Won | 2-1 | Southern League | Adam Parker,Mark Bridge | |
| 02/01/2006 | CHESHUNT | Won | 4-1 | Southern League | Josh Sozzo (3),Gavin Jaggard | |
| 25/10/2005 | Cheshunt | Won | 2-1 | Southern League | Josh Sozzo,Leeyon Phelan | |
| 06/01/2004 | Cheshunt | Lost | 0-3 | Herts Charity Cup | | |
| 29/01/2002 | Cheshunt | Won | 3-2 | Herts Charity Cup | Robbie Simpson,Carl Drew (2) | |
| 09/10/2001 | Cheshunt | Won | 1-0 | Herts Senior Cup | Robbie Simpson (Pen) | |
| 10/08/1999 | Cheshunt | Won | 2-1 | Herts Charity Cup | Jeran Meah,Gary Dixon | |
| 15/08/1998 | CHESHUNT | Won | 1-0 | Herts Charity Cup | Adam Turner | |
| 09/08/1994 | Cheshunt | Won | 5-1 | Herts Charity Cup | Gary Williams,Shaun Marshall,Tony Caines (2),Aaron Tighe | |
| 25/10/1983 | Cheshunt | Drawn | 0-0 | Herts Charity Cup | | |
| 06/01/1981 | Cheshunt | Lost | 1-2 | Herts Charity Cup | Terry Mortimer | |
| 23/12/1980 | CHESHUNT | Drawn | 2-2 | Herts Charity Cup | Steve Mahoney, | |
| 22/12/1979 | CHESHUNT | Won | 4-0 | Herts Senior Cup | Steve Hodge,Colin Barnes (3) | |
| 18/09/1975 | CHESHUNT | Lost | 1-2 | Herts Charity Cup | Steve Hodge | |
| 20/02/1975 | Cheshunt | Lost | 0-3 | East Anglian Cup | | |
| 08/02/1975 | CHESHUNT | Won | 2-0 | Herts Senior Cup | Howard Kettleborough (Pen),Neil Bunker | |
| 03/04/1973 | Cheshunt | Won | 1-0 | Herts Charity Cup | Tony Martin | |
| 23/12/1971 | Cheshunt | Lost | 0-2 | Herts Charity Cup | | |
| 15/04/1971 | CHESHUNT | Drawn | 0-0 | Premier Floodlit League | | |
| 29/03/1971 | Cheshunt | Lost | 0-3 | Premier Floodlit League | | |
| 05/05/1970 | Cheshunt | Won | 1-0 | Herts Senior Cup | Tony Brothers | |
| 03/03/1970 | Cheshunt | Won | 3-2 | Herts Charity Cup | Roy Cutler (Pen),Bernie Gogan (2) | |
| 04/10/1969 | CHESHUNT | Won | 3-1 | FA Cup | John Ashworth,Bernie Gogan (2) | |
| 27/02/1969 | CHESHUNT | Lost | 1-2 | Herts Senior Cup | Bernie Gogan | |
| 21/09/1968 | CHESHUNT | Won | 3-1 | FA Cup | Roy Cutler (2),Bobby Harper | |
| 16/12/1967 | CHESHUNT | Won | 4-1 | FA Amateur Cup | Roy Cutler (2),Ken Fulkes,Don Francis | |
| 14/02/1967 | CHESHUNT | Lost | 0-2 | Herts Floodlit League | | |
| 07/02/1967 | Cheshunt | Lost | 1-2 | Herts Floodlit League | Brian Gill | |
| 04/02/1967 | Cheshunt | Lost | 0-1 | Herts Senior Cup | | |
| 19/01/1957 | CHESHUNT | Won | 4-2 | Herts Senior Cup | Roger Simmonds (2),Peter Hammond,Alec Smith | |
| 18/02/1950 | Cheshunt | Lost | 0-1 | Herts Senior Cup | | |
| 12/03/1949 | CHESHUNT | Lost | 1-4 | Herts Senior Cup | Larry Dolan | |
| 20/11/1948 | CHESHUNT | Won | 2-0 | FA Amateur Cup | Frank Wingate,Frank Pateman | |