| Date | Opponents | Result | Score | Competition | Scorers |
| 20/04/1963 | Redhill | Won | 2-0 | Athenian League | Tommy Everitt,Peter Cox | |
| 27/10/1962 | REDHILL | Won | 2-1 | Athenian League | Tony Horne,Peter Hammond | |
| 17/02/1962 | Redhill | Lost | 1-4 | Athenian League | John Graves | |
| 19/08/1961 | REDHILL | Won | 4-2 | Athenian League | Roger Figg,Dennis Randall (2),Tony Horne | |
| 03/12/1960 | Redhill | Drawn | 1-1 | Athenian League | Roger Figg | |
| 01/10/1960 | REDHILL | Won | 4-0 | Athenian League | Terry Craddock,Roger Figg,Dennis Randall,Terry Waldock | |
| 28/11/1959 | Redhill | Drawn | 1-1 | Athenian League | Gordon Guile | |
| 22/08/1959 | REDHILL | Lost | 1-3 | Athenian League | Brian Figg | |
| 14/03/1959 | REDHILL | Drawn | 0-0 | Athenian League | | |
| 07/02/1959 | Redhill | Lost | 0-2 | Athenian League | | |
| 04/01/1958 | REDHILL | Won | 2-0 | Athenian League | Brian Figg,Jimmy Draper | |
| 30/11/1957 | Redhill | Lost | 0-4 | Athenian League | | |
| 30/03/1957 | Redhill | Won | 3-1 | Athenian League | Brian Figg,Peter Hammond,Mike Jordan | |
| 12/01/1957 | REDHILL | Won | 2-1 | FA Amateur Cup | Brian Figg,Roger Simmonds | |
| 01/12/1956 | REDHILL | Drawn | 1-1 | Athenian League | Peter Hammond | |
| 07/04/1956 | REDHILL | Lost | 0-2 | Athenian League | | |
| 03/12/1955 | Redhill | Lost | 1-3 | Athenian League | Peter Smith | |
| 02/04/1955 | Redhill | Lost | 0-6 | Athenian League | | |
| 04/12/1954 | REDHILL | Drawn | 1-1 | Athenian League | Frank Penn | |
| 24/04/1954 | REDHILL | Won | 2-0 | Athenian League | Keith Abbiss,Brian Smith | |
| 16/01/1954 | Redhill | Lost | 1-3 | Athenian League | Dave Sayers | |
| 07/02/1953 | REDHILL | Won | 2-0 | Athenian League | Alan Tillott,Brian Smith | |
| 31/01/1953 | Redhill | Won | 3-2 | Athenian League | Brian Smith,Arthur Ward,Ray Kitchener | |
| 09/02/1952 | Redhill | Lost | 0-5 | Athenian League | | |
| 18/08/1951 | REDHILL | Drawn | 2-2 | Athenian League | Frank Pateman,Billy Danskin | |
| 14/04/1951 | Redhill | Lost | 2-6 | Athenian League | G Longworth (2) | |
| 10/02/1951 | REDHILL | Drawn | 3-3 | Athenian League | Claude Brown,Harry Hillier (2) | |
| 25/02/1950 | REDHILL | Won | 1-0 | Athenian League | Arthur Ward | |
| 07/01/1950 | Redhill | Drawn | 2-2 | Athenian League | Jack Burr,Johnny Mockler | |
| 18/04/1949 | Redhill | Lost | 1-6 | Athenian League | Dick Cole | |
| 01/01/1949 | REDHILL | Won | 2-0 | Athenian League | Taffy Rogers,Frank Wingate | |
| 24/01/1948 | REDHILL | Won | 3-2 | Athenian League | Arthur Ward,Claude Brown,Frank Pateman (Pen) | |
| 10/01/1948 | Redhill | Won | 2-1 | Athenian League | Claude Brown, | |
| 11/01/1947 | REDHILL | Won | 2-1 | Athenian League | Frank Wingate,Larry Dolan (Pen) | |
| 07/09/1946 | Redhill | Won | 4-0 | Athenian League | Frank Wingate (3),Larry Dolan | |
| 26/01/1946 | Redhill | Won | 4-1 | Athenian League | Bill Saunders (2),Sam Hailey,Les Clarke | |
| 20/10/1945 | REDHILL | Won | 8-3 | Athenian League | Arthur Ward (2),D Needham (2),K Wilson (3),Les Clarke | |
| 19/11/1938 | REDHILL | Won | 3-0 | FA Amateur Cup | Les Clarke (2),Jack Hoar | |