| Date | Opponents | Result | Score | Competition | Scorers |
| 09/01/2023 | STEVENAGE | Won | 1-0 | Herts Senior Cup | Finley Wilkinson (Pen) | |
| 09/01/2023 | STEVENAGE | Won | 1-0 | Herts Senior Cup | Finley Wilkinson (Pen) | |
| 21/01/2014 | STEVENAGE | Won | 1-0 | Herts Senior Cup | Matt Lench | |
| 21/01/2014 | STEVENAGE | Won | 1-0 | Herts Senior Cup | Matt Lench | |
| 06/12/2011 | STEVENAGE | Lost | 0-2 | Herts Senior Cup | | |
| 06/12/2011 | STEVENAGE | Lost | 0-2 | Herts Senior Cup | | |
| 08/01/2002 | STEVENAGE BOROUGH | Won | 3-1 | Herts Senior Cup | Carl Drew,Matt Nolan,Robbie Simpson | |
| 01/05/2001 | Stevenage Borough | Won | 6-1 | Herts Charity Cup | Craig Rydeheard,Shaun Marshall (2),Matt Nolan (3) | |
| 09/01/2001 | STEVENAGE BOROUGH | Lost | 1-2 | Herts Senior Cup | Craig Rydeheard | |
| 28/10/1996 | Stevenage Borough | Lost | 2-4 | Herts Charity Cup | John Coley,Barry Dellar | |
| 15/08/1995 | Stevenage Borough | Lost | 0-3 | Herts Charity Cup | | |
| 04/04/1994 | STEVENAGE BOROUGH | Lost | 1-3 | Diadora Football League | Steve Conroy | |
| 27/12/1993 | Stevenage Borough | Won | 2-1 | Diadora Football League | Ian Scott,Steve Conroy | |
| 13/04/1992 | Stevenage Borough | Lost | 0-1 | Southern Floodlit Cup | | |
| 07/12/1991 | STEVENAGE BOROUGH | Drawn | 1-1 | Diadora Football League | Aaron Tighe | |
| 07/10/1991 | Stevenage Borough | Lost | 0-2 | Diadora Football League | | |
| 09/10/1990 | STEVENAGE BOROUGH | Lost | 1-2 | Herts Senior Cup | Jason Reed | |
| 11/08/1990 | STEVENAGE BOROUGH | Won | 3-1 | Herts Charity Cup | Mark Smith,Ian Lindsay, | |
| 08/08/1987 | STEVENAGE BOROUGH | Won | 2-1 | Herts Charity Cup | Steve Miller,Ian Lindsay | |
| 03/02/1987 | STEVENAGE BOROUGH | Lost | 0-4 | Herts Senior Cup | | |
| 14/02/1984 | Stevenage Borough | Won | 2-1 | Woolwich Trophy | Peter Harvey (2) | |
| 23/04/1983 | STEVENAGE BOROUGH | Won | 7-1 | Woolwich League | Paul Grant,Mick Every (2),Trevor Parker (2),Neil Prosser,Mark Lincoln | |
| 13/08/1981 | Stevenage Borough | Won | 1-0 | Woolwich Trophy | Paul Giggle | |
| 24/09/1973 | Stevenage Athletic | Won | 3-2 | FA Cup | Kevin Hammond,Alan Jackett (Pen),Paul Giggle | |
| 17/09/1973 | Stevenage Athletic | Drawn | 1-1 | FA Cup | John Kettleborough | |
| 15/09/1973 | STEVENAGE ATHLETIC | Drawn | 1-1 | FA Cup | Hugh Pratt | |
| 27/11/1967 | Stevenage Town | Won | 2-0 | Hitchin Centenary Cup | Terry Waldock,Bernie Gogan | |
| 26/10/1967 | STEVENAGE TOWN | Lost | 1-2 | East Anglian Cup | Terry Waldock | |
| 14/05/1967 | Stevenage Town | Lost | 1-3 | Hitchin Centenary Cup | Peter Adams | |
| 04/05/1967 | STEVENAGE TOWN | Won | 2-0 | Hitchin Centenary Cup | Albert Frost,Maurice Howkins | |
| 29/04/1967 | Stevenage Town | Lost | 0-2 | Hitchin Centenary Cup | | |
| 26/10/1965 | STEVENAGE TOWN | Won | 2-0 | Hitchin Centenary Cup | Ron Crawley (2) | |
| 11/10/1965 | Stevenage Town | Lost | 1-5 | Hitchin Centenary Cup | Ron Crawley | |
| 17/03/1962 | STEVENAGE TOWN | Won | 3-0 | Herts Charity Cup | Terry Waldock (2),Peter Cox | |
| 04/09/1961 | STEVENAGE TOWN | Won | 4-0 | Hitchin Centenary Cup | Terry Waldock,Ken Blake,John Graves,Tony Horne | |
| 22/11/1958 | Stevenage Town | Lost | 1-3 | Herts Senior Cup | Peter Hammond (Pen) | |
| 08/10/1958 | Stevenage Town | Won | 4-3 | FA Cup | Brian Figg,Peter Hammond (2-1 Pen),Mike Laing | |
| 28/11/1953 | STEVENAGE TOWN | Won | 2-1 | Herts Senior Cup | Johnny Ward,Ray Kitchener | |
| 29/11/1952 | Stevenage Town | Lost | 1-4 | Herts Senior Cup | Brian Smith | |
| 22/11/1952 | STEVENAGE TOWN | Drawn | 1-1 | Herts Senior Cup | Ray Kitchener | |
| 08/01/1949 | Stevenage Town | Won | 3-2 | Herts Senior Cup | Dick Cole (2),Taffy Rogers | |
| 10/01/1942 | STEVENAGE TOWN | Won | 6-1 | Herts Charity Cup (Wartime) | Dick Murphy (2),Sam Hailey (3),Dennis Chapman | |
| 21/12/1940 | STEVENAGE TOWN | Won | 6-1 | Herts Senior Cup (Wartime) | Les Dennis,Dennis Chapman (4),Colin Izzard | |
| 24/02/1940 | STEVENAGE TOWN | Won | 4-0 | Herts Senior Cup (Wartime) | Bill Westwood,Claude Brown (2),Arthur Ward | |
| 08/10/1938 | STEVENAGE TOWN | Won | 8-0 | FA Amateur Cup | Joe Goodyear,Sid Gentle,Dick Murphy (2),Sam Hailey (2),Les Clarke (Pen),Jack Hoar | |
| 23/10/1937 | Stevenage Town | Won | 4-2 | FA Amateur Cup | Eric Broadbent,Dick Murphy (2),Ivor Moyle | |
| 09/02/1935 | Stevenage Town | Won | 5-0 | Herts Senior Cup | Jimmy Walker (3),Cyril Walker,Les Clarke | |
| 06/10/1934 | STEVENAGE TOWN | Won | 3-0 | FA Amateur Cup | Cyril Walker,Jimmy Walker (2) | |
| 10/11/1928 | STEVENAGE TOWN | Won | 4-2 | Herts Charity Shield | Jack Davey,Charlie Evans (2),Albert Tasker | |