| Date | | Opponents | Competition | Score | Attendance | Scorers |
| 2023-24 |
| Sat | 07-Oct-2023 | | STAMFORD | FAT (Q3) | 2-3 | 362 | Daniel Idiakhoa, OG (Bartle) | |
| 2022-23 |
| Sat | 08-Oct-2022 | | REDDITCH UNITED | FAT (Q3) | 0-3 | 357 | - | |
| 2021-22 |
| Sat | 30-Oct-2021 | | LEISTON | FAT (Q3) | 1-3 | 278 | Ciaran Jones | |
| 2020-21 |
| Sat | 31-Oct-2020 | | HERNE BAY | FAT (Q3) | 3-1 | 443 | Alex Marsh, Callum Stead, OG (Harvey) | |
| Tue | 08-Dec-2020 | | MICKLEOVER | FAT (R1) | 3-0 | 203 | Luke Brown (3) | |
| Sat | 12-Dec-2020 | | PETERBOROUGH SPORTS | FAT (R2) | 0-4 | 385 | - | |
| 2019-20 |
| Sat | 09-Nov-2019 | | BEDFONT SPORTS | FAT (Q1) | 1-1 | 218 | Jhai Dhillon | |
| Tue | 12-Nov-2019 | | Bedfont Sports | FAT (Q1) | 1-1(Pens 4-5) | 71 | Dev Simms | |
| 2018-19 |
| Sat | 27-Oct-2018 | | HAYES & YEADING UNITED | FAT (Q1) | 0-1 | 317 | - | |
| 2017-18 |
| Sat | 28-Oct-2017 | | CHESHUNT | FAT (Q1) | 5-0 | 265 | Daniel Webb, Jack Green, Elliot Bailey, Brett Donnelly, Trey Charles | |
| Sat | 11-Nov-2017 | | Chesham United | FAT (Q2) | 1-3 | 297 | Elliot Bailey | |
| 2016-17 |
| Sat | 29-Oct-2016 | | Hayes & Yeading United | FAT (Q1) | 1-0 | 127 | Will Wright | |
| Sat | 12-Nov-2016 | | Biggleswade Town | FAT (Q2) | 1-1 | 325 | Josh Bickerstaff | |
| Mon | 14-Nov-2016 | | BIGGLESWADE TOWN | FAT (Q2) | 3-2 | 201 | Lucas Kirkpatrick, Robbie Burns (2) | |
| Sat | 26-Nov-2016 | | Burgess Hill Town | FAT (Q3) | 3-0 | 243 | Ben Walster, Brett Donnelly, Robbie Burns | |
| Sat | 10-Dec-2016 | | Chelmsford City | FAT (R1) | 0-1 | 469 | - | |
| 2015-16 |
| Sat | 31-Oct-2015 | | BURGESS HILL TOWN | FAT (Q1) | 3-2 | 190 | Robbie Burns, Jack Boyd, Callum Donnelly | |
| Sat | 14-Nov-2015 | | Haringey Borough | FAT (Q2) | 1-1 | 119 | OG (Scott) | |
| Mon | 16-Nov-2015 | | HARINGEY BOROUGH | FAT (Q2) | 3-0 | 109 | Brett Donnelly (2), Kane Smith | |
| Sat | 28-Nov-2015 | | Weston-super-Mare | FAT (Q3) | 0-4 | 175 | - | |
| 2014-15 |
| Sat | 01-Nov-2014 | | Burnham | FAT (Q1) | 2-2 | 102 | Ben Walster (Pen), Charlie Smith | |
| Mon | 03-Nov-2014 | | BURNHAM | FAT (Q1) | 0-2 | 112 | - | |
| 2013-14 |
| Sat | 19-Oct-2013 | | Wingate & Finchley | FAT (Q1) | 2-2 | 93 | Robbie Burns (2) | |
| Mon | 21-Oct-2013 | | WINGATE & FINCHLEY | FAT (Q1) | 0-1 | 114 | - | |
| 2012-13 |
| Sat | 29-Sep-2012 | | SITTINGBOURNE | FAT (R1) | 3-1 | 198 | Callum Donnelly, Josh Bickerstaff, John Frendo | |
| Sat | 27-Oct-2012 | | Wingate & Finchley | FAT (Q2) | 2-2 | 101 | John Frendo (2-1 Pen) | |
| Mon | 29-Oct-2012 | | WINGATE & FINCHLEY | FAT (Q2) | 3-0 | 171 | Zak Burke (3) | |
| Sat | 10-Nov-2012 | | Tonbridge Angels | FAT (Q3) | 1-2 | 513 | John Frendo (Pen) | |
| 2011-12 |
| Sat | 22-Oct-2011 | | Eastbourne Town | FAT (Q2) | 3-1 | 225 | John Frendo (3-1 Pen) | |
| Sat | 05-Nov-2011 | | LOWESTOFT TOWN | FAT (Q2) | 1-3 | 282 | John Frendo | |
| 2010-11 |
| Sat | 02-Oct-2010 | | Needham Market | FAT (PR) | 2-4 | 216 | Jamie Arlick, Luke Gregson | |
| 2009-10 |
| Sat | 03-Oct-2009 | | Folkestone Invicta | FAT (PR) | 1-0 | 255 | Jamie Arlick | |
| Sat | 17-Oct-2009 | | Canvey Island | FAT (Q1) | 2-1 | 285 | Jeff Hammond, Zak Burke | |
| Sat | 31-Oct-2009 | | GOSPORT BOROUGH | FAT (Q2) | 3-1 | 268 | Dean Gilbert, Steve Velandia, Jamie Arlick | |
| Sat | 21-Nov-2009 | | Billericay Town | FAT (Q3) | 0-0 | 327 | - | |
| Tue | 24-Nov-2009 | | BILLERICAY TOWN | FAT (Q3) | 0-1 | 219 | - | |
| 2008-09 |
| Sat | 18-Oct-2008 | | Aveley | FAT (Q1) | 2-1 | 108 | Ian Draycott, Paul Barnes | |
| Sat | 01-Nov-2008 | | RAMSGATE | FAT (Q2) | 3-6 | 246 | Tyron Sealey (Pen), Luke Gregson (2) | |
| 2007-08 |
| Sat | 20-Oct-2007 | | EASTBOURNE TOWN | FAT (Q1) | 3-0 | 165 | Mark Ducket, Shane Hill (Pen), Ricky Miller | |
| Sat | 03-Nov-2007 | | CINDERFORD TOWN | FAT (Q2) | 2-1 | 184 | Ricky Miller, Martin Standen (Pen) | |
| Sat | 24-Nov-2007 | | Carshalton Athletic | FAT (Q3) | 1-1 | 222 | David Iwediuno | |
| Tue | 27-Nov-2007 | | CARSHALTON ATHLETIC | FAT (Q3) | 1-2(AET) | 157 | Shane Hill (Pen) | |
| 2006-07 |
| Sat | 21-Oct-2006 | | Hampton & Richmond Borough | FAT (Q1) | 3-5 | 229 | Ryan Frater, Josh Sozzo, Mark Bridge | |
| 2005-06 |
| Sat | 15-Oct-2005 | | Team Bath | FAT (Q1) | 1-0 | 86 | Aaron Cavill | |
| Sat | 12-Nov-2005 | | BEDFORD TOWN | FAT (R2) | 1-2 | 603 | Wayne Mills | |
| 2004-05 |
| Sat | 06-Nov-2004 | | Team Bath | FAT (R1) | 0-3 | 135 | - | |
| 2003-04 |
| Sat | 01-Nov-2003 | | Wivenhoe Town | FAT (R1) | 0-0 | 222 | - | |
| Tue | 04-Nov-2003 | | WIVENHOE TOWN | FAT (R1) | 4-2 | 143 | James Ayres, Chris Dillon (2), Adam Parker | |
| Sat | 29-Nov-2003 | | Wealdstone | FAT (R2) | 0-1 | 263 | - | |
| 2002-03 |
| Sat | 02-Nov-2002 | | CHATHAM TOWN | FAT (R1) | 3-1 | 256 | Dean Brennan (Pen), Matt Nolan (2) | |
| Sat | 30-Nov-2002 | | Windsor & Eton | FAT (R2) | 1-3 | 195 | Matt Nolan | |
| 2001-02 |
| Sat | 03-Nov-2001 | | KINGSTONIAN | FAT (R1) | 1-2 | 383 | Shaun Marshall | |
| 2000-01 |
| Sat | 04-Nov-2000 | | Newport IoW | FAT (R1) | 2-2 | 370 | Adam Parker (2) | |
| Tue | 14-Nov-2000 | | NEWPORT IOW | FAT (R1) | 4-1 | 241 | Carl Williams (2), Adam Parker, Ian Scott | |
| Sat | 02-Dec-2000 | | Weymouth | FAT (R2) | 0-2 | 677 | - | |
| 1999-00 |
| Sat | 09-Oct-1999 | | HARROW BOROUGH | FAT (R1) | 1-1 | 291 | Keith Salton | |
| Tue | 12-Oct-1999 | | Harrow Borough | FAT (R1) | 1-2(AET) | 153 | Gary Dixon | |
| 1998-99 |
| Sat | 21-Nov-1998 | | Hereford United | FAT (R2) | 1-1 | 1382 | Adam Turner | |
| Mon | 30-Nov-1998 | | HEREFORD UNITED | FAT (R2) | 2-1 | 447 | Scott Cretton, Gary Dixon | |
| Mon | 25-Jan-1999 | | ENFIELD | FAT (R3) | 3-3 | 519 | Adam Parker (2), Gary Dixon | |
| Wed | 27-Jan-1999 | | Enfield | FAT (R3) | 1-0 | 304 | Adam Parker | |
| Sat | 06-Feb-1999 | | WESTON-SUPER-MARE | FAT (R4) | 2-1 | 549 | Zeema Abbey (2) | |
| Sat | 27-Feb-1999 | | FOREST GREEN ROVERS | FAT (R5) | 1-2 | 963 | Adam Parker | |
| 1997-98 |
| Sat | 18-Oct-1997 | | ERITH & BELVEDERE | FAT (Q1) | 7-1 | 267 | Carl Williams, Gary Williams (2), Rudi Hall (2), Tony Clark, Jon Bone | |
| Sat | 08-Nov-1997 | | BARTON ROVERS | FAT (Q2) | 3-0 | 349 | Barry Dellar (2), Gary Williams | |
| Sat | 29-Nov-1997 | | BOREHAM WOOD | FAT (Q3) | 0-2 | 321 | - | |
| 1996-97 |
| Sat | 19-Oct-1996 | | Ashford Town | FAT (Q1) | 1-4 | 544 | Jon Bone | |
| 1995-96 |
| Sat | 25-Nov-1995 | | BOGNOR REGIS TOWN | FAT (Q3) | 1-2 | 394 | Ken Gillard | |
| 1994-95 |
| Sat | 26-Nov-1994 | | Halesowen Town | FAT (Q3) | 0-4 | 676 | - | |
| 1993-94 |
| Sat | 18-Sep-1993 | | BOREHAM WOOD | FAT (Q1) | 0-2 | 366 | - | |
| 1992-93 |
| Sat | 19-Sep-1992 | | BISHOP'S STORTFORD | FAT (Q1) | 3-1 | 371 | Gary Williams, David Taylor, Paul Quarman | |
| Sat | 17-Oct-1992 | | Wembley | FAT (Q2) | 1-3 | 89 | Nigel Hann | |
| 1991-92 |
| Sat | 21-Sep-1991 | | GRAYS ATHLETIC | FAT (Q1) | 2-1 | 325 | Paul Quarman, Sean Pearson | |
| Sat | 19-Oct-1991 | | ST ALBANS CITY | FAT (Q2) | 2-3 | 430 | Mark Smith, Martin Maguire | |
| 1990-91 |
| Sat | 20-Oct-1990 | | Hayes | FAT (Q2) | 1-1 | 304 | Jason Reed | |
| Tue | 23-Oct-1990 | | HAYES | FAT (Q2) | 1-2 | 482 | Mark Smith | |
| 1989-90 |
| Sat | 21-Oct-1989 | | WEMBLEY | FAT (Q2) | 1-0 | 397 | Steve Conroy | |
| Sat | 02-Dec-1989 | | KINGSTONIAN | FAT (Q3) | 1-1 | 440 | Ian Edet | |
| Tue | 05-Dec-1989 | | Kingstonian | FAT (Q3) | 1-3 | 423 | Paul Neufville | |
| 1988-89 |
| Sat | 24-Sep-1988 | | Thanet United | FAT (Q1) | 0-1 | 219 | - | |
| 1987-88 |
| Sat | 03-Oct-1987 | | Finchley | FAT (Q1) | 1-1 | 77 | Ian Lindsay | |
| Tue | 06-Oct-1987 | | FINCHLEY | FAT (Q1) | 2-0 | 167 | Alan Cosby, Mick Every | |
| Sat | 31-Oct-1987 | | Carshalton Athletic | FAT (Q2) | 2-1 | 189 | Jimmy Holmes (Pen), OG (Warmington) | |
| Sat | 21-Nov-1987 | | Farnborough Town | FAT (Q3) | 1-3 | 359 | Mick Every | |
| 1986-87 |
| Sat | 04-Oct-1986 | | Tilbury | FAT (Q1) | 3-1 | 92 | Trevor Parker, Robbie O'Keefe, OG (Gorbell) | |
| Sat | 01-Nov-1986 | | Hampton | FAT (Q2) | 2-1 | 205 | Carl Stock (2) | |
| Tue | 25-Nov-1986 | | CARSHALTON ATHLETIC | FAT (Q3) | 1-0 | 221 | Robbie O'Keefe (Pen) | |
| Tue | 23-Dec-1986 | | BOREHAM WOOD | FAT (R1) | 1-1 | 218 | Lee Payne | |
| Mon | 29-Dec-1986 | | Boreham Wood | FAT (R1) | 4-2 | 213 | Robbie O'Keefe, Ian Lindsay, Mick Every (2) | |
| Sat | 24-Jan-1987 | | Barnet | FAT (R2) | 1-1 | 1031 | Robbie O'Keefe | |
| Tue | 27-Jan-1987 | | BARNET | FAT (R2) | 0-5 | 813 | - | |
| 1985-86 |
| Sat | 05-Oct-1985 | | DUNSTABLE | FAT (Q1) | 1-2 | 250 | Ian Lindsay | |
| 1984-85 |
| Sat | 20-Oct-1984 | | HAMPTON | FAT (Q1) | 1-4 | 205 | Ray Brammer (Pen) | |
| 1983-84 |
| Sat | 17-Dec-1983 | | Carshalton Athletic | FAT (Q3) | 0-1 | 139 | - | |
| 1982-83 |
| Sat | 18-Dec-1982 | | CORBY TOWN | FAT (Q3) | 1-4 | 264 | Alan Cosby | |
| 1981-82 |
| Mon | 04-Jan-1982 | | LEYTONSTONE-ILFORD | FAT (Q3) | 3-0 | 340 | Mick Every, Andy Pearson (2-1 Pen) | |
| Mon | 18-Jan-1982 | | Dagenham | FAT (R1) | 0-1 | 641 | - | |
| 1980-81 |
| Sat | 11-Oct-1980 | | WARE | FAT (Q1) | 3-1 | 327 | Terry Mortimer, Robin Chandler, Steve Mahoney | |
| Sat | 08-Nov-1980 | | BILLERICAY TOWN | FAT (Q2) | 3-0 | 645 | Bobby Folds, Mick Small, Steve Mahoney | |
| Wed | 03-Dec-1980 | | Dover Athletic | FAT (Q3) | 5-2 | 263 | Steve Mahoney (3), Mick Small (2) | |
| Sat | 10-Jan-1981 | | TOOTING & MITCHAM UNITED | FAT (R1) | 2-1 | 422 | David Dodds, Paul Giggle | |
| Sat | 31-Jan-1981 | | Boston United | FAT (R2) | 1-0 | 1452 | OG (Annable) | |
| Sat | 21-Feb-1981 | | Bangor City | FAT (R3) | 0-1 | 639 | - | |
| 1979-80 |
| Sat | 13-Oct-1979 | | SPALDING UNITED | FAT (Q1) | 4-0 | 396 | Bill Baldry, Paul Giggle, Colin Barnes (2) | |
| Sat | 10-Nov-1979 | | Alvechurch | FAT (Q2) | 0-0 | 316 | - | |
| Tue | 13-Nov-1979 | | ALVECHURCH | FAT (Q2) | 2-4 | 479 | Steve Hodge, Colin Barnes | |
| 1978-79 |
| Sat | 02-Dec-1978 | | Hayes | FAT (Q3) | 0-1 | | - | |
| 1977-78 |
| Sat | 03-Dec-1977 | | Wellingborough Town | FAT (Q3) | 3-3 | 239 | Paul Giggle, Kevin Mulkern, Peter Watson | |
| Tue | 06-Dec-1977 | | WELLINGBOROUGH TOWN | FAT (Q3) | 2-1 | 464 | Jose Whishaw, Peter Watson (Pen) | |
| Sat | 14-Jan-1978 | | Merthyr Tydfil | FAT (R1) | 1-4 | 950 | Kevin Mulkern | |
| 1976-77 |
| Sat | 30-Oct-1976 | | Gorleston | FAT (Q1) | 1-0 | 178 | Peter Watson | |
| Sat | 27-Nov-1976 | | Letchworth Garden City | FAT (Q2) | 2-0 | 950 | Neil Bunker (2) | |
| Sat | 18-Dec-1976 | | KING'S LYNN | FAT (Q3) | 3-0 | 602 | Paul Giggle (2), Neil Bunker | |
| Tue | 18-Jan-1977 | | ROMFORD | FAT (R1) | 4-0 | 535 | Paul Giggle (3), Neil Bunker | |
| Sat | 05-Feb-1977 | | Bangor City | FAT (R2) | 2-2 | 1478 | Jose Whishaw, Paul Giggle | |
| Tue | 08-Feb-1977 | | BANGOR CITY | FAT (R2) | 2-1 | 936 | Paul Giggle (2) | |
| Sat | 26-Feb-1977 | | SCARBOROUGH | FAT (R3) | 0-0 | 1869 | - | |
| Wed | 02-Mar-1977 | | Scarborough | FAT (R3) | 1-3 | 3483 | Paul Giggle | |
| 1975-76 |
| Sat | 11-Oct-1975 | | ST ALBANS CITY | FAT (Q1) | 1-1 | 518 | Gary Conroy | |
| Tue | 14-Oct-1975 | | St Albans City | FAT (Q1) | 0-1 | | - | |
| 1974-75 |
| Sat | 21-Sep-1974 | | ROTHWELL TOWN | FAT (PR) | 4-1 | 343 | Howard Kettleborough (Pen), Neil Bunker (2), OG (Aldwinckle) | |
| Sat | 12-Oct-1974 | | Stowmarket | FAT (Q1) | 0-0 | 172 | - | |
| Sat | 26-Oct-1974 | | STOWMARKET | FAT (Q1) | 5-0(AET) | 464 | Peter Watson (3), Dennis Bevis, Dave Archibald | |
| Sat | 09-Nov-1974 | | Harwich & Parkeston | FAT (Q2) | 1-0 | 404 | Tony Brothers | |
| Sat | 30-Nov-1974 | | BARNET | FAT (Q3) | 1-0 | 640 | Dave Archibald | |
| Sat | 11-Jan-1975 | | BEDFORD TOWN | FAT (R1) | 1-1 | 1050 | Paul Giggle | |
| Mon | 13-Jan-1975 | | Bedford Town | FAT (R1) | 1-3 | 1501 | Howard Kettleborough (Pen) | |
