| Date | | Opponents | Competition | Score | Attendance | Scorers |
| Sat | 10-Aug-2024 | | BROMSGROVE SPORTING | SL | 1-3 | 547 | Rio Deall | |
| Tue | 13-Aug-2024 | | Stamford | SL | 0-2 | 394 | - | |
| Sat | 17-Aug-2024 | | AFC Telford United | SL | 4-5 | 1017 | Coree Wilson, Liam Brooks (2), Jack Dreyer | |
| Tue | 20-Aug-2024 | | HERTFORD TOWN | HCC (R1) | 3-0 | 192 | Liam Brooks, George Morrall, Coree Wilson | |
| Sat | 24-Aug-2024 | | KETTERING TOWN | SL | 0-3 | 598 | - | |
| Mon | 26-Aug-2024 | | Barwell | SL | 0-4 | 372 | - | |
| Sat | 31-Aug-2024 | | BERKHAMSTED | FAC (Q1) | 0-2 | 427 | - | |
| Sat | 07-Sep-2024 | | ALVECHURCH | SL | 0-1 | 509 | - | |
| Tue | 10-Sep-2024 | | BISHOP'S STORTFORD | SL | 1-2 | 378 | George Morrall | |
| Sat | 21-Sep-2024 | | Halesowen Town | SL | 4-0 | 716 | Lewis Barker, Rio Deall, George Morrall, Joseph Chidyausiku | |
| Tue | 24-Sep-2024 | | Royston Town | SL | 2-2 | 500 | Coree Wilson (2-1 Pen) | |
| Sat | 05-Oct-2024 | | Hashtag United | FAT (Q3) | 0-1 | 137 | - | |
| Tue | 08-Oct-2024 | | ST ALBANS CITY | HCC (QF) | 1-1 | 241 | Daniel Stokoe | |
| Sat | 12-Oct-2024 | | SPALDING UNITED | SL | 2-1 | 719 | Daniel Stokoe, Coree Wilson (Pen) | |
| Tue | 15-Oct-2024 | | LEISTON | SL | 1-1 | 378 | Coree Wilson | |
| Sat | 19-Oct-2024 | | STOURBRIDGE | SL | 1-5 | 641 | Rio Deall | |
| Tue | 22-Oct-2024 | | LOWESTOFT TOWN | SL | 2-5 | 294 | Enock Ekongo, Rio Deall | |
| Tue | 29-Oct-2024 | | HADLEY | HSC (R1) | 3-0 | 232 | Joseph Chidyausiku, Daniel Stokoe (Pen), Ciaran Jones | |
| Sat | 02-Nov-2024 | | Banbury United | SL | 2-1 | 709 | Daniel Stokoe, Henry Snee | |
| Sat | 09-Nov-2024 | | Biggleswade Town | SL | 1-1 | 365 | Ciaran Jones | |
| Sat | 16-Nov-2024 | | HARBOROUGH TOWN | SL | 3-0 | 825 | Luke Stokoe, Daniel Stokoe (Pen), Ciaran Jones | |
| Sat | 23-Nov-2024 | | STRATFORD TOWN | SL | 0-1 | 441 | - | |
| Sat | 30-Nov-2024 | | St Ives Town | SL | 1-3 | 330 | Henry Snee | |
| Tue | 03-Dec-2024 | | HEMEL HEMPSTEAD TOWN | HSC (R2) | 0-1 | 164 | - | |
| Sat | 14-Dec-2024 | | AFC Sudbury | SL | 1-1 | 317 | Henry Snee | |
| Sat | 21-Dec-2024 | | STAMFORD | SL | 0-2 | 677 | - | |
| Thu | 26-Dec-2024 | | Bedford Town | SL | 1-2 | 952 | OG (Mensah) | |
| Sat | 28-Dec-2024 | | AFC TELFORD UNITED | SL | 3-3 | 752 | Harry Titchmarsh, Luke Stokoe, Henry Snee (Pen) | |
| Wed | 01-Jan-2025 | | BARWELL | SL | 2-0 | 485 | Daniel Stokoe (Pen), Ciaran Jones | |
| Sat | 04-Jan-2025 | | Bromsgrove Sporting | SL | 1-1 | 679 | Rio Deall | |
| Sat | 11-Jan-2025 | | Harborough Town | SL | 0-1 | 402 | - | |
| Tue | 14-Jan-2025 | | REDDITCH UNITED | SL | 2-1 | 311 | Harry Titchmarsh, Henry Snee | |
| Sat | 18-Jan-2025 | | BIGGLESWADE TOWN | SL | 3-1 | 742 | Rio Deall, Liam Brooks (Pen), Enock Ekongo | |
| Sat | 25-Jan-2025 | | Leiston | SL | 0-2 | 210 | - | |
| Sat | 01-Feb-2025 | | Stourbridge | SL | 1-3 | 573 | Lewis Franklin | |
| Sat | 08-Feb-2025 | | BANBURY UNITED | SL | 1-0 | 672 | Bradley Smith | |
| Sat | 15-Feb-2025 | | Lowestoft Town | SL | 1-2 | 307 | Luke Stokoe (Pen) | |
| Sat | 22-Feb-2025 | | ST IVES TOWN | SL | 1-1 | 649 | Lewis Franklin | |
| Sat | 01-Mar-2025 | | Stratford Town | SL | 1-1 | 833 | Daniel Stokoe (Pen) | |
| Sat | 08-Mar-2025 | | Bishop's Stortford | SL | 2-3 | 577 | Daniel Stokoe (Pen), Lewis Franklin | |
| Sat | 15-Mar-2025 | | HALESOWEN TOWN | SL | 1-2 | 702 | Bradley Bell | |
| Sat | 22-Mar-2025 | | Spalding United | SL | 2-3 | 440 | Rio Deall (2) | |
| Sat | 29-Mar-2025 | | ROYSTON TOWN | SL | 2-2 | 871 | Jacob Hutchinson, Liam Brooks | |
| Sat | 05-Apr-2025 | | Kettering Town | SL | 2-2 | 1167 | Dominic Martins, Rio Deall | |
| Sat | 12-Apr-2025 | | AFC SUDBURY | SL | 0-1 | 705 | - | |
| Fri | 18-Apr-2025 | | Alvechurch | SL | 1-4 | 250 | Lewis Franklin | |
| Mon | 21-Apr-2025 | | BEDFORD TOWN | SL | 1-2 | 1093 | Jacob Hutchinson | |
| Sat | 26-Apr-2025 | | Redditch United | SL | 0-4 | 596 | - | |
| Date | | Opponents | Competition | Score | Attendance | Scorers |
| Sat | 29-Jul-2023 | | ROYSTON TOWN | HCC (QF) | 2-1 | 319 | Isaac Galliford, Diogo Freitas-Gouveia | |
| Sat | 05-Aug-2023 | | ALVECHURCH | SL | 2-0 | 438 | Jack Snelus, Finley Wilkinson | |
| Sat | 12-Aug-2023 | | Long Eaton United | SL | 2-1 | 263 | Layne Eadie, Finley Wilkinson | |
| Tue | 15-Aug-2023 | | Needham Market | SL | 0-2 | 291 | - | |
| Sat | 19-Aug-2023 | | ST IVES TOWN | SL | 3-2 | 468 | Isaac Galliford, Diogo Freitas-Gouveia, Finley Wilkinson | |
| Sat | 26-Aug-2023 | | Mickleover | SL | 1-2 | 334 | Daniel Idiakhoa | |
| Mon | 28-Aug-2023 | | ROYSTON TOWN | SL | 1-2 | 726 | Bradley Bell | |
| Sat | 02-Sep-2023 | | WELWYN GARDEN CITY | FAC (Q1) | 2-1 | 540 | Bradley Bell, Daniel Idiakhoa | |
| Sat | 09-Sep-2023 | | REDDITCH UNITED | SL | 2-2 | 410 | Diogo Freitas-Gouveia, Kye Tearle | |
| Sat | 16-Sep-2023 | | AFC SUDBURY | FAC (Q2) | 3-0 | 449 | Bradley Bell, Finley Wilkinson (2-1 Pen) | |
| Sat | 23-Sep-2023 | | BARWELL | SL | 0-0 | 524 | - | |
| Tue | 26-Sep-2023 | | Kettering Town | SL | 4-0 | 631 | Bradley Bell, Daniel Idiakhoa, Finley Wilkinson, Isaac Galliford | |
| Sat | 30-Sep-2023 | | KETTERING TOWN | FAC (Q3) | 0-1 | 832 | - | |
| Mon | 02-Oct-2023 | | LEVERSTOCK GREEN | HSC (R1) | 1-1 | 113 | Temi Akinbusoye | |
| Sat | 07-Oct-2023 | | STAMFORD | FAT (Q3) | 2-3 | 362 | Daniel Idiakhoa, OG (Bartle) | |
| Sat | 14-Oct-2023 | | COALVILLE TOWN | SL | 4-3 | 513 | Jack Snelus, Finley Wilkinson (3) | |
| Sat | 21-Oct-2023 | | Bromsgrove Sporting | SL | 1-2 | 579 | Finley Wilkinson | |
| Sat | 28-Oct-2023 | | AFC SUDBURY | SL | 2-1 | 544 | Finley Wilkinson (Pen), Jack Snelus | |
| Tue | 31-Oct-2023 | | Stratford Town | SL | 1-0 | 323 | Toby Syme | |
| Sat | 04-Nov-2023 | | Halesowen Town | SL | 3-1 | 721 | Finley Wilkinson, John Freeman (2) | |
| Sat | 11-Nov-2023 | | STAMFORD | SL | 1-2 | 690 | Layne Eadie | |
| Sat | 18-Nov-2023 | | AFC Telford United | SL | 0-0 | 1095 | - | |
| Tue | 28-Nov-2023 | | Stourbridge | SL | 2-0 | 321 | Isaac Galliford, Bradley Bell | |
| Sat | 02-Dec-2023 | | LEAMINGTON | SL | 1-2 | 551 | Bradley Bell | |
| Tue | 05-Dec-2023 | | St Albans City | HCC (SF) | 0-2 | 271 | - | |
| Mon | 11-Dec-2023 | | LEISTON | SL | 1-4 | 350 | Kye Tearle | |
| Sat | 16-Dec-2023 | | St Ives Town | SL | 2-1 | 389 | Arnold Matshazi (2) | |
| Sat | 23-Dec-2023 | | MICKLEOVER | SL | 2-2 | 640 | Layne Eadie (2) | |
| Tue | 26-Dec-2023 | | Royston Town | SL | 0-1 | 643 | - | |
| Sat | 30-Dec-2023 | | BERKHAMSTED | SL | 1-3 | 690 | Finley Wilkinson | |
| Tue | 09-Jan-2024 | | St Albans City | HSC (R1) | 0-6 | 293 | - | |
| Sat | 13-Jan-2024 | | LONG EATON UNITED | SL | 2-3 | 680 | Daniel Idiakhoa, Arnold Matshazi | |
| Mon | 15-Jan-2024 | | Redditch United | SL | 0-3 | 1223 | - | |
| Sat | 20-Jan-2024 | | Alvechurch | SL | 1-2 | 306 | Josh Popoola | |
| Sat | 27-Jan-2024 | | KETTERING TOWN | SL | 0-1 | 725 | - | |
| Sat | 03-Feb-2024 | | Barwell | SL | 0-2 | 226 | - | |
| Sat | 10-Feb-2024 | | STRATFORD TOWN | SL | 3-4 | 473 | Layne Eadie, Josh Popoola (2) | |
| Sat | 17-Feb-2024 | | Coalville Town | SL | 0-1 | 379 | - | |
| Sat | 24-Feb-2024 | | BROMSGROVE SPORTING | SL | 1-2 | 611 | Jack Snelus | |
| Sat | 02-Mar-2024 | | AFC Sudbury | SL | 0-1 | 374 | - | |
| Sat | 16-Mar-2024 | | Leamington | SL | 0-3 | 625 | - | |
| Sat | 23-Mar-2024 | | AFC TELFORD UNITED | SL | 1-1 | 757 | Finley Wilkinson | |
| Fri | 29-Mar-2024 | | NEEDHAM MARKET | SL | 0-2 | 792 | - | |
| Mon | 01-Apr-2024 | | Berkhamsted | SL | 2-1 | 281 | Finley Wilkinson, Connor Vincent | |
| Sat | 06-Apr-2024 | | Leiston | SL | 0-2 | 182 | - | |
| Sat | 13-Apr-2024 | | HALESOWEN TOWN | SL | 0-1 | 618 | - | |
| Sat | 20-Apr-2024 | | Stamford | SL | 0-2 | 611 | - | |
| Sat | 27-Apr-2024 | | STOURBRIDGE | SL | 0-0 | 1141 | - | |
| Date | | Opponents | Competition | Score | Attendance | Scorers |
| Sat | 06-Aug-2022 | | Barwell | SL | 2-1 | 337 | Jack Morrell, Finley Wilkinson | |
| Sat | 13-Aug-2022 | | RUSHALL OLYMPIC | SL | 0-0 | 419 | - | |
| Tue | 16-Aug-2022 | | AFC Rushden & Diamonds | SL | 2-1 | 361 | Steve Cawley, Jack Morrell (Pen) | |
| Sat | 20-Aug-2022 | | BASFORD UNITED | SL | 0-0 | 409 | - | |
| Sat | 27-Aug-2022 | | Bromsgrove Sporting | SL | 1-2 | 656 | Finley Wilkinson | |
| Mon | 29-Aug-2022 | | NEEDHAM MARKET | SL | 1-0 | 529 | Finley Wilkinson | |
| Sat | 03-Sep-2022 | | HEYBRIDGE SWIFTS | FAC (Q1) | 0-3 | 424 | - | |
| Tue | 13-Sep-2022 | | Bedford Town | SL | 0-3 | 466 | - | |
| Mon | 19-Sep-2022 | | WELWYN GARDEN CITY | HSC (R1) | 1-0 | 231 | Ashley Hay | |
| Sat | 24-Sep-2022 | | Stourbridge | SL | 0-3 | 959 | - | |
| Mon | 26-Sep-2022 | | ST IVES TOWN | SL | 1-1 | 303 | Finley Wilkinson | |
| Sat | 08-Oct-2022 | | REDDITCH UNITED | FAT (Q3) | 0-3 | 357 | - | |
| Mon | 10-Oct-2022 | | LEISTON | SL | 0-3 | 326 | - | |
| Sat | 15-Oct-2022 | | HEDNESFORD TOWN | SL | 1-1 | 481 | OG (Bailey) | |
| Sat | 22-Oct-2022 | | Tamworth | SL | 1-2 | 668 | Jack Snelus | |
| Tue | 25-Oct-2022 | | Stratford Town | SL | 2-1 | 241 | Ashley Hay, Diogo Freitas-Gouveia | |
| Sat | 29-Oct-2022 | | POTTERS BAR TOWN | HSC (R2) | 3-2 | 339 | Diogo Freitas-Gouveia, Steve Cawley (Pen), Ashley Hay | |
| Tue | 01-Nov-2022 | | Nuneaton Borough | SL | 1-1 | 304 | Finley Wilkinson | |
| Sat | 05-Nov-2022 | | Ilkeston Town | SL | 1-3 | 607 | Steve Cawley | |
| Sat | 12-Nov-2022 | | ALVECHURCH | SL | 2-1 | 478 | Steve Cawley, Diogo Freitas-Gouveia | |
| Mon | 14-Nov-2022 | | COALVILLE TOWN | SL | 2-2 | 293 | Diogo Freitas-Gouveia, Bradley Bell | |
| Sat | 19-Nov-2022 | | Royston Town | SL | 2-4 | 528 | Diogo Freitas-Gouveia (2) | |
| Mon | 21-Nov-2022 | | AFC RUSHDEN & DIAMONDS | SL | 2-1 | 240 | Jack Snelus, Stan Georgiou | |
| Sat | 26-Nov-2022 | | MICKLEOVER | SL | 4-1 | 443 | Diogo Freitas-Gouveia, Steve Cawley (2), Bradley Bell | |
| Mon | 28-Nov-2022 | | REDDITCH UNITED | SL | 2-1 | 276 | Jack Snelus, Ashley Hay | |
| Sat | 03-Dec-2022 | | Basford United | SL | 2-0 | 213 | Diogo Freitas-Gouveia, Ashley Hay | |
| Sat | 17-Dec-2022 | | Rushall Olympic | SL | 1-3 | 258 | Stan Georgiou | |
| Mon | 26-Dec-2022 | | KINGS LANGLEY | SL | 2-4 | 665 | Lewis Barker, Ashley Hay | |
| Mon | 02-Jan-2023 | | Needham Market | SL | 0-3 | 302 | - | |
| Sat | 07-Jan-2023 | | BROMSGROVE SPORTING | SL | 2-0 | 473 | Diogo Freitas-Gouveia, Ashley Hay | |
| Mon | 09-Jan-2023 | | STEVENAGE | HSC (R3) | 1-0 | 361 | Finley Wilkinson (Pen) | |
| Sat | 14-Jan-2023 | | Mickleover | SL | 2-1 | 302 | Bradley Bell, Ashley Hay | |
| Sat | 28-Jan-2023 | | BEDFORD TOWN | SL | 0-0 | 823 | - | |
| Sat | 04-Feb-2023 | | St Ives Town | SL | 2-3 | 297 | Ashley Hay, Diogo Freitas-Gouveia | |
| Sat | 11-Feb-2023 | | STOURBRIDGE | SL | 1-1 | 539 | Jack Snelus | |
| Tue | 14-Feb-2023 | | Coalville Town | SL | 1-5 | 451 | Finley Wilkinson | |
| Sat | 18-Feb-2023 | | NUNEATON BOROUGH | SL | 1-1 | 558 | Bradley Bell | |
| Mon | 20-Feb-2023 | | BARWELL | SL | 1-1 | 338 | Finley Wilkinson | |
| Sat | 25-Feb-2023 | | Leiston | SL | 0-0 | 241 | - | |
| Tue | 28-Feb-2023 | | Cheshunt | HSC (SF) | 2-0 | 241 | Toby Syme, Ashley Hay | |
| Sat | 04-Mar-2023 | | TAMWORTH | SL | 0-1 | 555 | - | |
| Sat | 18-Mar-2023 | | Hednesford Town | SL | 0-1 | 351 | - | |
| Sat | 25-Mar-2023 | | STRATFORD TOWN | SL | 1-0 | 553 | Josh Allen | |
| Wed | 29-Mar-2023 | | Berkhamsted | HSC (Fin) | 2-2 | 461 | Finley Wilkinson, Jack Snelus | |
| Sat | 01-Apr-2023 | | Redditch United | SL | 1-2 | 343 | Jack Snelus | |
| Sat | 08-Apr-2023 | | ROYSTON TOWN | SL | 1-0 | 834 | Toby Syme | |
| Sat | 15-Apr-2023 | | Alvechurch | SL | 3-1 | 256 | Jack Snelus, Diogo Freitas-Gouveia, Finley Wilkinson | |
| Tue | 18-Apr-2023 | | Kings Langley | SL | 1-0 | 124 | Finley Wilkinson | |
| Sat | 22-Apr-2023 | | ILKESTON TOWN | SL | 3-1 | 812 | Josh Coldicott-Stevens, Diogo Freitas-Gouveia, Ashley Hay | |
